Comments on: When the Desh-RTP-dream comes true and the beauty of Bhairavi unfolds!!! http://aparna-a.com/2008/12/29/when-the-desh-rtp-dream-comes-true-and-the-beauty-of-bhairavi-unfolds/ Wed, 23 May 2012 19:31:09 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.2.2 By: Aparna http://aparna-a.com/2008/12/29/when-the-desh-rtp-dream-comes-true-and-the-beauty-of-bhairavi-unfolds/#comment-119723 Aparna Fri, 02 Jan 2009 04:56:28 +0000 http://aparna-a.com/2008/12/29/when-the-desh-rtp-dream-comes-true-and-the-beauty-of-bhairavi-unfolds/#comment-119723 Blogeswari, :) Will surely let you know. Anyway, I guess Sanjay himself will be posting in his blog if and when the recording is released. Then that means you didn’t fully read the concert list I posted since I had mentioned the name of the composer of tunbam nergayil in my post ;) Prasanna, I’ll post it in the coming weeks. I have to anyway, soon write since I myself won’t be able to understand any of my scribbling, read notes, after sometime! No comparison. Both their singing styles are so unique. Sathej, Oh ok. Thank you PRG, Welcome to my blog! Some earlier recording of Oho kalame might be there in sangeethapriya. Otherwise, I have no idea where you can hear that song. Sathyamurthy, I am not writing these posts here for the sake of reviewing a concert. It’s another fact that my posts are, anyway, not reviews and don’t have technical jargons. Blogeswari,
:) Will surely let you know. Anyway, I guess Sanjay himself will be posting in his blog if and when the recording is released.

Then that means you didn’t fully read the concert list I posted since I had mentioned the name of the composer of tunbam nergayil in my post ;)

Prasanna,
I’ll post it in the coming weeks. I have to anyway, soon write since I myself won’t be able to understand any of my scribbling, read notes, after sometime!

No comparison. Both their singing styles are so unique.

Sathej,
Oh ok. Thank you

PRG,
Welcome to my blog! Some earlier recording of Oho kalame might be there in sangeethapriya. Otherwise, I have no idea where you can hear that song.

Sathyamurthy,
I am not writing these posts here for the sake of reviewing a concert. It’s another fact that my posts are, anyway, not reviews and don’t have technical jargons.

]]> By: R Sathyamurthy http://aparna-a.com/2008/12/29/when-the-desh-rtp-dream-comes-true-and-the-beauty-of-bhairavi-unfolds/#comment-119105 R Sathyamurthy Wed, 31 Dec 2008 13:34:30 +0000 http://aparna-a.com/2008/12/29/when-the-desh-rtp-dream-comes-true-and-the-beauty-of-bhairavi-unfolds/#comment-119105 Aparna, There are so many technical jargons used when describing a Carnatic music concert, not only in your blog, but even elsewhere, that I feel that it alienates music appreciation by people who do not know Carnatic music. For enjoying music one really doesn't need to be a musician knowing all technical things. So why not review the concerts or individual songs with least possible technical jargon? Will there be nothing left to review if the jargon is not used? Why is that Carnatic music being alienated as a form music only for knowledgeable (that is Carnatic knowledge) people? Why can't it be presented as a form of Music? Will that not take this music more to the masses? Didn't the movies Sindhu Bairavi, Shankarabaranam, Kadhal Oviyam achieve this? I am not writing this to criticize you but just expressing my thought on this subject of music appreciation and review. :) Aparna,

There are so many technical jargons used when describing a Carnatic music concert, not only in your blog, but even elsewhere, that I feel that it alienates music appreciation by people who do not know Carnatic music.

For enjoying music one really doesn’t need to be a musician knowing all technical things. So why not review the concerts or individual songs with least possible technical jargon? Will there be nothing left to review if the jargon is not used?

Why is that Carnatic music being alienated as a form music only for knowledgeable (that is Carnatic knowledge) people? Why can’t it be presented as a form of Music? Will that not take this music more to the masses?

Didn’t the movies Sindhu Bairavi, Shankarabaranam, Kadhal Oviyam achieve this?

I am not writing this to criticize you but just expressing my thought on this subject of music appreciation and review.

:)

]]> By: PRG http://aparna-a.com/2008/12/29/when-the-desh-rtp-dream-comes-true-and-the-beauty-of-bhairavi-unfolds/#comment-119026 PRG Wed, 31 Dec 2008 08:36:40 +0000 http://aparna-a.com/2008/12/29/when-the-desh-rtp-dream-comes-true-and-the-beauty-of-bhairavi-unfolds/#comment-119026 This is the first time I write a comment in your blog. Iam also an ardent fan of sanjay . I missed sanjay's concert at vidya Bharati. But somehow made it in Music academy. The RTP in jonpuri was excellent. I missed sanjay 's MMU telecast and could hear only the vrittam before 'o o kaalame' in you tube.Can you suggest that how I can hear the song. This is the first time I write a comment in your blog. Iam also an ardent fan of sanjay . I missed sanjay’s concert at vidya Bharati. But somehow made it in Music academy. The RTP in jonpuri was excellent.
I missed sanjay ’s MMU telecast and could hear only the vrittam before ‘o o kaalame’ in you tube.Can you suggest that how I can hear the song.

]]> By: Sathej http://aparna-a.com/2008/12/29/when-the-desh-rtp-dream-comes-true-and-the-beauty-of-bhairavi-unfolds/#comment-118374 Sathej Tue, 30 Dec 2008 02:49:59 +0000 http://aparna-a.com/2008/12/29/when-the-desh-rtp-dream-comes-true-and-the-beauty-of-bhairavi-unfolds/#comment-118374 //I think that line was also sung in different speeds during the neraval.// Not during the Neraval. The line was sung in Trikalam in line with what is usually done for a Pallavi. Sathej //I think that line was also sung in different speeds during the neraval.//

Not during the Neraval. The line was sung in Trikalam in line with what is usually done for a Pallavi.

Sathej

]]> By: Prasanna http://aparna-a.com/2008/12/29/when-the-desh-rtp-dream-comes-true-and-the-beauty-of-bhairavi-unfolds/#comment-118365 Prasanna Tue, 30 Dec 2008 01:55:19 +0000 http://aparna-a.com/2008/12/29/when-the-desh-rtp-dream-comes-true-and-the-beauty-of-bhairavi-unfolds/#comment-118365 Good to see you enjoying the season...if you can post on the lec-dems whenever possible,it'd be helpful. Want to do a quick comparion of the 2 Bhairavis?? Regards, Prasanna Good to see you enjoying the season…if you can post on the lec-dems whenever possible,it’d be helpful.

Want to do a quick comparion of the 2 Bhairavis??

Regards,
Prasanna

]]> By: Blogeswari http://aparna-a.com/2008/12/29/when-the-desh-rtp-dream-comes-true-and-the-beauty-of-bhairavi-unfolds/#comment-118363 Blogeswari Tue, 30 Dec 2008 01:48:05 +0000 http://aparna-a.com/2008/12/29/when-the-desh-rtp-dream-comes-true-and-the-beauty-of-bhairavi-unfolds/#comment-118363 RTP in Desh!!! wow! Not fair, I missed it! Please please do me a favour. When the CD/ cassette of this concert gets released, could you please inform me? I have never heard an RTP in Desh! btw I didn't know till I saw the Margazhi concert on TV that Tunbam nergayil was a Dandapani desikar's composition for Bharadidasan's lyrics. RTP in Desh!!! wow! Not fair, I missed it!
Please please do me a favour. When the CD/ cassette of this concert gets released, could you please inform me? I have never heard an RTP in Desh!

btw I didn’t know till I saw the Margazhi concert on TV that Tunbam nergayil was a Dandapani desikar’s composition for Bharadidasan’s lyrics.

]]>